Liberty or life: the Aotearoa New Zealand perspective
Justin Barry-Walsh
July 29, 2024
Cambridge University Press
Liberty or life: the Aotearoa New Zealand perspective
Abstract
A description is provided of the current situation in Aotearoa New Zealand with regard to compulsory treatment of people with schizophrenia. This is placed within the context of homelessness in New Zealand and the provision of services to the incarcerated mentally ill. There are high rates of homelessness and incarceration and services are struggling to meet their needs. This is particularly a problem for the indigenous population. The current Mental Health Act allows for compulsory treatment of people who as a result of schizophrenia are seriously impaired in their capacity to care for themselves, and this will include people where there is a nexus between homelessness and their illness. The Mental Health Act is being reformed, with a new act likely to emphasize autonomy and capacity to a greater degree. Finally, the author considers the learnings from 5 years working within the Fixated Threat Assessment Centre, which provides a unique perspective on these issues.
Even though I am always telling people about what I see through my stories, only when I was watching my friend pray did I make a connection. I realized that I’ve been referencing a painting featuring Phillippe Pinel unshackling a mental patient from chains in 1876, but weirdly this was the first time I asked, “isn’t this the same mythology”? We’d have to ask Freud why I repressed this parallel. Maybe because it is just too much to bear-the fact that mental health wards 250 years later are worse- so it has never really consciously occurred to me.
